The spousal right of election in New York is the single most important reason you cannot fully disinherit a husband or wife in this state: under EPTL 5-1.1-A, a surviving spouse may reject whatever the will leaves them and instead claim a statutory “elective share” worth the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the deceased spouse’s net estate. The genuinely surprising part is that this one-third is calculated not only against the probate estate but against an expanded “net estate” that sweeps in joint accounts, “in trust for” (Totten trust) accounts, retirement plans, and even certain gifts made during the marriage. In other words, a New Yorker who tries to write a spouse out of the will by moving everything into beneficiary-designated and jointly held assets has, in most cases, accomplished nothing — the law simply pulls those assets back into the math.
What the Right of Election Is and Where It Comes From
New York is not a community-property state. There is no automatic 50/50 division of marital assets at death. Instead, the Legislature protects surviving spouses through a forced-share statute: Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) section 5-1.1-A. The policy behind it is centuries old — the idea that a person should not be able to leave a lifelong partner destitute while directing the estate to children, a charity, or a paramour.
The right belongs only to a surviving spouse. It is a personal right that must be affirmatively exercised; if the spouse does nothing, it is waived. It applies whether the deceased spouse died with a will (testate) or without one (intestate), and even applies where the deceased left the spouse something — just less than the elective-share amount. In that case the spouse elects to “top up” the inheritance to the statutory minimum.
The Core Numbers
The elective share is the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the “net estate.” If the net estate is under $50,000, the surviving spouse generally takes the entire estate up to that floor. Above $150,000, the one-third fraction controls. This is a fixed statutory formula — it does not change based on the length of the marriage, fault, or whether there were children from a prior relationship.
What Counts: The Expanded “Net Estate”
The reason the right of election has real teeth is that EPTL 5-1.1-A reaches beyond the will. The “net estate” used to calculate the one-third share includes “testamentary substitutes” — non-probate transfers that function like gifts at death. Understanding what is and is not counted is the heart of any elective-share analysis.
| Asset type | Counted in the net estate? |
|---|---|
| Property passing under the will (probate estate) | Yes |
| Joint bank accounts & jointly held property (decedent’s contribution) | Yes — testamentary substitute |
| Totten (“in trust for”) and POD/TOD accounts | Yes |
| Retirement accounts & pensions (IRA, 401(k)) | Yes (subject to limits / ERISA interplay) |
| Lifetime gifts made within one year of death | Yes (Gifts Causa Mortis & gifts > annual exclusion) |
| Property over which decedent held a presently exercisable general power of appointment | Yes |
| Life insurance payable to a third party | No — excluded by statute |
| Gifts completed more than one year before death | Generally no |
| Property the surviving spouse already receives (counts against the share) | Offset |
Two points trip people up. First, life insurance is the major escape hatch: proceeds paid to someone other than the estate are not testamentary substitutes and are not counted. Second, anything the surviving spouse already receives outright — a joint account that passes to them, a TOD designation in their favor, an outright bequest — is credited against the one-third. The spouse does not get to keep those and also take a full third on top.
How the Math Actually Works
- Add up the probate estate plus all testamentary substitutes to get the “net estate.”
- Subtract debts, funeral and administration expenses, and estate taxes to reach the net figure.
- Multiply by one-third (or use the $50,000 floor if larger).
- Credit everything the spouse is already receiving from the estate and from testamentary substitutes.
- The remaining balance — the “net elective share” — is contributed proportionally by the other beneficiaries.
Concrete New York Scenarios
The abstract formula becomes clearer in the kind of situations that walk into a Surrogate’s Court every week across the five boroughs and beyond.
Scenario 1: The “I left her a dollar” will
A Brooklyn husband executes a will leaving his entire $1.2 million estate to his adult children and $1 to his wife. She files a right of election. Her elective share is one-third of roughly $1.2 million — about $400,000 — and the children’s bequests are reduced proportionally to fund it. The token bequest does almost nothing to defeat her statutory right.
Scenario 2: Everything in beneficiary designations
A Queens widow’s late husband held no probate assets at all — the house was jointly owned with his daughter, and his $800,000 in bank and brokerage accounts named the daughter as POD beneficiary. The estate “passing under the will” is essentially zero. But because joint property and POD accounts are testamentary substitutes, the wife’s one-third is calculated against the full $800,000-plus, and the daughter must contribute to satisfy the elective share.
Scenario 3: The second marriage and the prenup
A Manhattan executive remarries late in life and the couple signs a prenuptial agreement in which each waives the right of election under EPTL 5-1.1-A(e). When he dies leaving everything to children from his first marriage, the new spouse has no valid election to make — a properly executed, acknowledged waiver is fully enforceable. This is the cleanest way to opt out of the statute.
A surviving spouse generally has six months from the issuance of letters testamentary or letters of administration — and in no event later than two years after the date of death — to serve and file a written notice of election. Miss the window and the right is usually lost.
The Deadline and the Procedure
Timing is where many otherwise valid claims die. Under EPTL 5-1.1-A(d)(1), the surviving spouse must serve a written notice of election on the personal representative and file it with the Surrogate’s Court within six months after letters are granted, with an absolute outer limit of two years from death. The court can extend the six-month deadline for “reasonable cause,” but the two-year ceiling is firm. Because the clock often starts when the probate process formally begins and letters issue, a spouse who is not paying attention to the appointment of the executor can run out of time without realizing it.
Who is Disqualified as a “Surviving Spouse”
EPTL 5-1.2 lists circumstances in which a survivor is treated as not a surviving spouse and therefore has no right of election at all. These include:
- A final divorce or annulment valid in New York before death;
- A marriage void as incestuous or bigamous;
- Abandonment of the deceased spouse that continued until death;
- Failure to support the deceased spouse when there was a duty to do so;
- A valid written waiver or release of the right (typically a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement).
Common Mistakes That Cost Spouses (and Estates) Money
- Assuming “non-probate” assets are safe from the spouse. Joint accounts, Totten trusts, and POD/TOD designations are the most common testamentary substitutes — moving money into them rarely defeats the election.
- Letting the six-month deadline lapse. Grief, out-of-state heirs, and slow estate administration cause spouses to miss the window. Calendar it from the date letters issue.
- Relying on an informal prenup. A waiver must be in writing, signed, and acknowledged like a deed. An unsigned or improperly notarized agreement will not bar the election.
- Confusing the elective share with the family exemption. EPTL 5-3.1 set-asides (the spousal “exempt property,” up to roughly $92,500 in specified items and cash) are separate from and additional to the elective share.
- Executors ignoring the offset. The personal representative must credit assets the spouse already receives; failing to do so over- or under-funds the share and invites litigation. Managing this is part of an executor’s fiduciary duties.
When to Call a New York Estate Attorney
The right of election sits at the intersection of contested wills, non-probate transfers, tax, and strict deadlines — and the dollar amounts are usually large. A surviving spouse considering an election, an executor served with a notice of election, or a couple in a second marriage trying to structure their plans around the statute should all get counsel early. An experienced NYC estate planning lawyer can run the net-estate math, identify which assets are testamentary substitutes, evaluate whether a waiver is enforceable, and file the notice of election before the deadline closes the door.
For couples doing planning while both are alive, the same analysis runs in reverse: if you want to leave a spouse less than one-third — or nothing — only a valid, acknowledged waiver under EPTL 5-1.1-A(e) reliably accomplishes it. Life-insurance planning and lifetime gifting outside the one-year window can also reduce exposure, but those tools must be coordinated carefully. You can review the governing statute directly through the New York EPTL, but applying it to a real estate in 2026 — across the Surrogate’s Courts of Kings, New York, Queens, Nassau, Suffolk, and Westchester Counties — is rarely a do-it-yourself project.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the spousal right of election in New York?
It is a statutory right under EPTL 5-1.1-A that lets a surviving spouse reject what a will leaves them and instead claim an ‘elective share’ equal to the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the deceased spouse’s net estate, so a spouse cannot be fully disinherited.
How much is the elective share in New York?
The elective share is the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate. The net estate includes the probate estate plus testamentary substitutes like joint accounts, Totten trusts, and POD/TOD designations, minus debts, expenses, and taxes.
What is the deadline to file a right of election in New York?
A surviving spouse generally must serve and file a written notice of election within six months after letters testamentary or letters of administration are issued, and in no event later than two years after the date of death. The six-month period can be extended for reasonable cause; the two-year limit is firm.
Can joint accounts and beneficiary designations avoid the spouse's elective share?
Usually not. Joint accounts, Totten (‘in trust for’) accounts, POD/TOD designations, and many retirement assets are ‘testamentary substitutes’ that are counted in the net estate. Life insurance payable to a third party is a notable exception that is excluded.
Can a spouse waive the right of election in New York?
Yes. Under EPTL 5-1.1-A(e), a spouse can waive the right of election in a written agreement that is signed and acknowledged like a deed, typically a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement. A properly executed waiver fully bars the election.
When does a survivor lose the status of 'surviving spouse'?
Under EPTL 5-1.2, a survivor has no right of election if there was a valid divorce or annulment before death, a void (incestuous or bigamous) marriage, abandonment of the deceased that continued until death, failure to support when required, or a valid written waiver.
Is the elective share the same as the family exemption?
No. The EPTL 5-3.1 set-aside for exempt property (certain household items, a vehicle, and cash, up to specified limits) is separate from and additional to the elective share under EPTL 5-1.1-A.
Which Surrogate's Court handles a right of election claim?
The notice of election is filed in the Surrogate’s Court of the county where the deceased spouse was domiciled, such as Kings (Brooklyn), New York, Queens, Nassau, Suffolk, or Westchester County, where the estate is being administered.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.